ClawAudit verdict

smart-email

smart-email-assistant

45
🟠 Risky
Significant concerns — only install if you understand the risks

The skill reads IMAP credentials and API keys from environment variables and automatically dispatches email content to external services (Telegram, DingTalk, WeChat Work, Feishu), which constitutes sending potentially sensitive data to third parties; while this matches the stated purpose, the broad credential handling and automatic outbound dispatch warrant user awareness.

⚠ Flagged for review — coarse, uncorroborated signal, not a confirmed exploit. Review the config yourself before installing.

Automated static analysis — not a human review. ClawAudit flags capabilities, not confirmed intent, and can produce false positives. Disagree with this verdict? Use Dispute below.

65
security
90
transparency
70
maintenance

Findings (4)

Pattern match high

Accesses OpenClaw config/secrets directly

README_EN.md · code · ~/.openclaw/.env

Pattern match medium

subprocess execution — runs system commands from Python

src/smart_email/__main__.py · prose · downgraded · subprocess.run(

Pattern match low

Python os.getenv — reads environment variable

src/smart_email/__main__.py · prose · downgraded · os.getenv(

Pattern match low

Python shutil file operation — copies/moves/deletes files

src/smart_email/__main__.py · prose · downgraded · shutil.rmtree(

Why the tier is capped

Execution sink present in raw bytes (Hard Floor: class D). Final tier capped at Caution — cannot be lifted by any downgrade, example-payload opt-in, or allowlist.

Permissions & capabilities

No declared permissions — minimal attack surface.

Is this flag fair?

Check another skill Browse the registry Auditing your own skills or configs? Use the API